Montauk Mashup Scavenger Hunt in Long Island
Long Island, United States

Montauk Mashup Scavenger Hunt

Outty Ranking 54 3.5 · 4 traveler reviews2 hoursFrom $27

Pick your date

Highlighted days have spots open. Grey days are sold out or not running.

September 2026

SMTWTFS

Loading live availability

Who is going?

Adults

Age 13 and over

2

Children

Age 12 and under

0

Select a highlighted day to see live departure times and the exact price for your group.

From, per person$27
View availability on Viator

Free cancellation up to 24 hours before. Same price on Viator, Outty earns a commission.

Instant mobile ticketSpots available today

Outty Ranking

54/100

Worth a Look. Our proprietary evaluation. How we score

Traveler rating

3.5/5

Based on 4 traveler reviews. Ratings and reviews provided by Viator and Tripadvisor.

Quick answer

Is Montauk Mashup Scavenger Hunt worth booking?

Montauk Mashup Scavenger Hunt is a 2-hour experience in Long Island, United States, from $27 per person. It scores 54 out of 100 on the Outty Ranking, which we label “Worth a Look, based on a 3.5/5 rating across 4 reviews. Cancellation is free up to 24 hours before the start time. Same-day spots are currently showing.

Outty Ranking
54 / 100
Rating
3.5/5 (4)
Duration
2 hours
From
$27 per person

Our very unique, immersive adventures are the only ones of their kind. We provide your very own remote, interactive, live host to assist and encourage you through your phone. We are an event design company offering scave

What you get

    About this experience

    Our very unique, immersive adventures are the only ones of their kind. We provide your very own remote, interactive, live host to assist and encourage you through your phone. We are an event design company offering scavenger hunts and other events in 300+ cities in North America and beyond. Our specially handcrafted adventures are equal parts tour, creative challenge, detective hunt, and social experiment! Guests get to discover in an alternate reality our favorite hidden gems off the beaten trail and creatively interpret fun art, history, and culture clues—for points! They get to enjoy fame and glory while appearing on our website’s international leaderboard, no matter what their score. They get to essentially race other teams in other cities, even if they don’t have competitors who have signed up in their city that day. Get ready to discover unusual oddities, laugh out loud, and make the experience your own!

    What's included

    Included

    • Remote interactive live guide (Must provide domestic phone or WhatsApp number)
    • Digital Scavenger Hunt Document
    • Leaderboard standing
    • Choice to extend the hunt for free
    • Future company alumni discounts

    Where it starts and ends

    Meeting point

    Long Island

    Begin outside in front of the starting location.

    Hotel pickup

    No pickup: everyone meets at the start point.

    Ends at

    Begin outside in front of the starting location.

    Options you can book

    • Private Hunt (For 10 guests)

    • Montauk Mashup Scavenger Hunt

    Before you book

    Cancellation
    For a full refund, cancel at least 24 hours before the scheduled departure time.
    Languages
    en
    Ticket
    Mobile Only
    Runs on
    Every day
    Group size
    Up to 15 travelers per booking
    Operated by
    Alley Kat Adventures

    Know before you go

    • Wheelchair accessible
    • Infants and small children can ride in a pram or stroller
    • Service animals allowed
    • Public transportation options are available nearby
    • Suitable for all physical fitness levels

    Photos

    Montauk Mashup Scavenger Hunt in Long Island, photo 2Montauk Mashup Scavenger Hunt in Long Island, photo 3Montauk Mashup Scavenger Hunt in Long Island, photo 4Montauk Mashup Scavenger Hunt in Long Island, photo 5Montauk Mashup Scavenger Hunt in Long Island, photo 6

    What travelers are saying

    Outty’s summary of the themes that recur across 4 traveler reviews. Written by us, not quoted from reviewers.

    The guide

    1 mention

    Travelers single out the guide as the reason the experience works.

    Knowledge and storytelling

    1 mention

    Reviewers describe the commentary as informative rather than scripted.

    Pace and timing

    1 mention

    Several reviewers comment on how the schedule is paced.

    Traveler reviews

    4 verified traveler reviews for Montauk Mashup Scavenger Hunt. Ratings and reviews provided by Viator and Tripadvisor.

    5 star
    2
    4 star
    0
    3 star
    1
    2 star
    0
    1 star
    1
    Sort
    488donnao · November 2025

    Fun in Montauk

    the 4 of us had a great time with this unique, fun experience. it was easy and very relaxed. we toured around montauk looking for clues and meeting people. we tend to be a friendly group who make friends easily but this pushed us a little more. we were celebrating a friend's birthday, off season and cooler weather doesn't provide much beach time. this was an excellent way to have some fun. we highly recommend abs we will do it again on our travels. our 1 suggestion is to have a longer list of things to look for, that part was fun. being creative was part of our quest. we found unicorns all over!!

    via Tripadvisor

    TripMaven1 · June 2025

    Don’t waste your money on this

    To say that this was a waste of money and time is an understatement. The scavenger hunt was silly, the cost was ridiculous. There are so many fun options in Montauk. This isn’t one of them.

    via Tripadvisor

    Z4966PHrebeccar · May 2024

    Montauk Scavenger Hunt

    We had a great time even though we (just my husband and I) weren't really sure what we were getting ourselves into. This is not your typical hunt, and we went in thinking we were going to hit all the historical highlights of Montauk. If that's what you're looking for this may not be the best experience. On the other hand, it was super fun, and we did enjoy getting out of our comfort zone. We also learned a lot about Montauk history and its fun facts. This experience was in the off-season which was both good and bad. Good in that it wasn't crowded when walking around but having lots of people around may have made it more fun. MaryAnna was a great host and encouraged us to reach the top of the leaderboard. Her responses were quick and witty. We would definitely do this again in another city.

    via Tripadvisor

    lowez2 · May 2024

    Scavenger Hunt

    Not bad at all, but beware, it is a virtual guide. Originally thought it was a meet-up with a group of others. I had a great time nevertheless.

    via Tripadvisor

    Good to know

    Duration
    2 hours
    Free cancellation
    Up to 24h before
    Minimum age to book
    All ages
    Availability
    Bookable today
    Runs on
    Every day
    Price range
    $27 to $250
    Hotel pickup
    No pickup, meet at start point
    Booked in 30 days
    1
    Verdict
    Worth a Look

    Why this scores 54

    The Outty Ranking is a weighted composite. Here is how this experience performed on each component.

    Traveler sentiment (30% weight)53
    Review evidence (18% weight)30
    Booking momentum (14% weight)16
    Value for money (12% weight)100
    Listing quality (10% weight)85
    Local standing (8% weight)29
    Booking flexibility (8% weight)100

    Montauk Mashup Scavenger Hunt: questions travelers ask

    Practical detail on this experience, plus the wider planning questions for Long Island.

    How much does Montauk Mashup Scavenger Hunt cost?

    +

    Prices start at $27 per person. The final price depends on the date, the time slot and the number of travelers, and peak weekends in Long Island usually price higher than midweek mornings. Live pricing and remaining availability are confirmed on the booking screen before you pay.

    How long does Montauk Mashup Scavenger Hunt take?

    +

    Plan for about 2 hours from start to finish, not counting travel to the meeting point. Most travelers leave another 30 minutes on either side so the rest of the day in Long Island is not rushed.

    Is Montauk Mashup Scavenger Hunt worth it?

    +

    It holds an Outty Ranking of 54 out of 100, which we label "Worth a Look". That score blends traveler sentiment (3.5/5 across 4 reviews), the depth of that review evidence, recent booking momentum, value for money against comparable last minute in Long Island, and how flexible the cancellation terms are.

    Can I cancel or reschedule Montauk Mashup Scavenger Hunt?

    +

    Yes. Cancel free up to 24 hours before the start time for a full refund. Inside that window the booking is non-refundable, and no-shows are not refunded.

    Is Montauk Mashup Scavenger Hunt suitable for kids and families?

    +

    Yes, all ages are welcome. Families should still weigh the 2-hour running time, and strollers are easier on the earlier, quieter departures.

    How far in advance should I book Montauk Mashup Scavenger Hunt?

    +

    Around 1 people booked this in the last 30 days, so popular slots go early. Two to three weeks ahead is comfortable in shoulder season, while summer weekends and holidays in Long Island can sell out a month out. Same-day spots do open up when other travelers cancel, so it is worth checking if you are already in town.

    What should I bring or wear?

    +

    Bring photo ID, your booking confirmation on your phone, a refillable water bottle and comfortable shoes. Dress for the weather in Long Island and add a light layer if any part of the 2-hour experience runs outdoors or after sunset.

    Where does Montauk Mashup Scavenger Hunt start and how do I get there?

    +

    The exact meeting point and directions are on your voucher once you book, and they sit in central Long Island within reach of public transport. Arrive 15 minutes early: late arrivals are treated as no-shows by most operators.

    What are the best things to do in Long Island?

    +

    Long Island covers North Fork winery tours, Hamptons beach days, Gold Coast mansion visits and fishing or sailing charters, most reachable as a day trip from Manhattan. On Outty we rank every Long Island experience on the same 0 to 100 scale, and alongside this one the highest scorers right now include Private Transfer in Black SUV to or from JFK, LGA, EWR, Skip the Lines Reliable Comfortable and stress free Rides, Black SUV Transfer From or To JFK, LGA, EWR - All Fees Included. The city page groups everything into most popular, highest reviewed, last minute and family-friendly so you can build a day around what actually delivers.

    When is the best time to visit Long Island?

    +

    May to October, with harvest tastings peaking in September. Booking patterns follow the same curve: prices and queues climb in peak weeks, while shoulder season gives you better availability on the top-ranked experiences and more room to change plans.

    How many days do you need in Long Island?

    +

    Three full days covers the headline sights without sprinting. A workable rhythm is one anchor experience each morning, such as this one, an unhurried afternoon in a single neighborhood, then a food or nightlife booking in the evening. Five days lets you add a day trip outside the city.

    Do I book through Outty or through the operator?

    +

    Outty ranks and explains the experiences, then hands you to Viator to complete the booking with the operator directly. The price is the same as booking on Viator yourself, and Outty earns an affiliate commission on the referral, which is how the rankings stay free to read.

    Ready to lock in your spot?

    Pick a date, choose your group, and see the exact price for Montauk Mashup Scavenger Hunt.

    Pick your date