
Crime and Punishment
Traveler rating
5.0/5
Based on 2 traveler reviews. Ratings and reviews provided by Viator and Tripadvisor.
Quick answer
Is Crime and Punishment worth booking?
Crime and Punishment is a 2-hour experience in Edinburgh, United Kingdom, from $34 per person. It scores 55 out of 100 on the Outty Ranking, which we label “Worth a Look”, based on a 5/5 rating across 2 reviews. This booking is non-refundable, so pick your date carefully. Same-day spots are currently showing.
- Outty Ranking
- 55 / 100
- Rating
- 5/5 (2)
- Duration
- 2 hours
- From
- $34 per person
"Award-winning 2-hour dark walking tour through Edinburgh's sinister UNESCO World Heritage Old Town. Led by expert guide in authentic handmade costume, uncover chilling true crimes behind St Giles Cathedral's witch trials, Royal Mile's infamous hangings, and Grassmarket's body snatchers Burke & Hare. Discover Deacon Brodie's double life inspiring Dr Jekyll & Mr Hyde, Victoria Street's Wizard of West Bow Major John Weir, Parliament Square's execution sites, and Greyfriars' grave-robbing horrors. Meet Dr Robert Knox's anatomy secrets, the cannibal son of Marquis of Queensberry, and George IV Bridge's criminal underworld. Experience bagpipe music while exploring Edinburgh's darkest secrets. Perfect 5-star reviews, intimate small groups. This isn't just sightseeing - it's investigating real murders, body snatching, and supernatural crimes that shocked Scotland. Book your authentic Edinburgh crime investigation today!"
What you get
About this experience
"Award-winning 2-hour dark walking tour through Edinburgh's sinister UNESCO World Heritage Old Town. Led by expert guide in authentic handmade costume, uncover chilling true crimes behind St Giles Cathedral's witch trials, Royal Mile's infamous hangings, and Grassmarket's body snatchers Burke & Hare. Discover Deacon Brodie's double life inspiring Dr Jekyll & Mr Hyde, Victoria Street's Wizard of West Bow Major John Weir, Parliament Square's execution sites, and Greyfriars' grave-robbing horrors. Meet Dr Robert Knox's anatomy secrets, the cannibal son of Marquis of Queensberry, and George IV Bridge's criminal underworld. Experience bagpipe music while exploring Edinburgh's darkest secrets. Perfect 5-star reviews, intimate small groups. This isn't just sightseeing - it's investigating real murders, body snatching, and supernatural crimes that shocked Scotland. Book your authentic Edinburgh crime investigation today!"
What's included
Included
- 2hr Historical Walking Tour
- Guide
Not included
- Gratuities
What you'll see and do
Edinburgh Old Town
"Award-winning 2-hour dark walking tour through Edinburgh's sinister UNESCO World Heritage Old Town. Led by expert guide in authentic handmade costume, uncover chilling true crimes behind St Giles Cathedral's witch trials, Royal Mile's infamous hangings, and Grassmarket's body snatchers Burke & Hare. Discover Deacon Brodie's double life inspiring Dr Jekyll & Mr Hyde, Victoria Street's Wizard of West Bow Major John Weir, Parliament Square's execution sites, and Greyfriars' grave-robbing horrors. Meet Dr Robert Knox's anatomy secrets, the cannibal son of Marquis of Queensberry, and George IV Bridge's criminal underworld. Experience bagpipe music while exploring Edinburgh's darkest secrets. Perfect 5-star reviews, intimate small groups. This isn't just sightseeing - it's investigating real murders, body snatching, and supernatural crimes that shocked Scotland. Book your authentic Edinburgh crime investigation today!"
120 minutes here
Where it starts and ends
Meeting point
Edinburgh
In front of St Giles Cathedral, by the Statue, Look for your costumed Guide carrying a large umbrella with our company name on it. Note, we do not always use an umbrella as it depends upon the weather. Your guide will be in full costume which is easy to spot.
Hotel pickup
No pickup: everyone meets at the start point.
Ends at
In front of St Giles Cathedral, by the Statue, Look for your costumed Guide carrying a large umbrella with our company name on it. Note, we do not always use an umbrella as it depends upon the weather. Your guide will be in full costume which is easy to spot.
Before you book
- Cancellation
- All sales are final. No refund is available for cancellations.
- Languages
- en
- Ticket
- Mobile Only
- Runs on
- Wed, Thu, Fri, Sat, Sun
- Group size
- Up to 30 travelers per booking
- Operated by
- Walk The Old Town
Know before you go
- Not recommended for travelers with spinal injuries
- Service animals allowed
- Public transportation options are available nearby
- Infants and small children can ride in a pram or stroller
- All areas and surfaces are wheelchair accessible
- Transportation options are wheelchair accessible
- Wheelchair accessible
- Suitable for all physical fitness levels
Photos






Traveler reviews
2 verified traveler reviews for Crime and Punishment. Ratings and reviews provided by Viator and Tripadvisor.
Edinburgh historical visit
Discovering Edinburgh through a historical "crime and punishment" visit should be on everyone to do list. Our guide Charlotte, is not only an expert of the city, she is also a passionate and unique adviser. My friend and I had the priviledge to delve into history through a private visit. One of the best thing we experienced during our stay in Edinburgh. Thank you Charlotte. Take care of yourself. Wishing you the best.
Response from the operator: Dear Visitor I cannot thank you enough for your kind words. I LOVE my job and it shows and one of the best things I get to do is share stories with people of similar interests such as yourselves. It is such a joy to hear that you enjoyed your wee sojourn with me through Edinburgh's cobbled street. It was a pleasure to meet you both. I wish you a merry festive season and thank you for choosing Walk The Old Town. Best wishes Charlotte
via Tripadvisor
Informative and fun!
We met our tour guide Charlotte, who took us on the Crime and punishment walking tour. Not only was Charlotte very knowledgeable and charismatic, she was such a pleasure to spend time with. We spent 2 hours on a lovely paced walk finding out different parts of history of Edinburgh and the surrounding area. I was really worried about my mobility issues but Charlotte was very understanding and didn't rush us at all. If you are visiting we would highly recommend you book a tour.
Response from the operator: Dear Visitor Thank you so much for your glowing review, it means more than words can say. I had such a marvellous time showing you around. At Walk The Old Town we pride ourselves in making our tours accessible to everyone regardless of their mobility level to ensure that all gets a change to see this glorious city. Thank you so much for choosing my wee company and for the kind words. Best Wishes Charlotte
via Tripadvisor
Good to know
- Duration
- 2 hours
- Free cancellation
- Non-refundable
- Minimum age to book
- All ages
- Availability
- Bookable today
- Runs on
- Wed, Thu, Fri, Sat, Sun
- Hotel pickup
- No pickup, meet at start point
- Booked in 30 days
- 1
- Verdict
- Worth a Look
Why this scores 55
The Outty Ranking is a weighted composite. Here is how this experience performed on each component.
Crime and Punishment: questions travelers ask
Practical detail on this experience, plus the wider planning questions for Edinburgh.
How much does Crime and Punishment cost?
+
Prices start at $34 per person. The final price depends on the date, the time slot and the number of travelers, and peak weekends in Edinburgh usually price higher than midweek mornings. Live pricing and remaining availability are confirmed on the booking screen before you pay.
How long does Crime and Punishment take?
+
Plan for about 2 hours from start to finish, not counting travel to the meeting point. Most travelers leave another 30 minutes on either side so the rest of the day in Edinburgh is not rushed.
Is Crime and Punishment worth it?
+
It holds an Outty Ranking of 55 out of 100, which we label "Worth a Look". That score blends traveler sentiment (5/5 across 2 reviews), the depth of that review evidence, recent booking momentum, value for money against comparable food & drink in Edinburgh, and how flexible the cancellation terms are.
Can I cancel or reschedule Crime and Punishment?
+
No. This experience is sold on a non-refundable basis, so only book a date you are confident about. Similar experiences in the city do offer free cancellation if flexibility matters more than price.
Is Crime and Punishment suitable for kids and families?
+
Yes, all ages are welcome. Families should still weigh the 2-hour running time, and strollers are easier on the earlier, quieter departures.
How far in advance should I book Crime and Punishment?
+
Around 1 people booked this in the last 30 days, so popular slots go early. Two to three weeks ahead is comfortable in shoulder season, while summer weekends and holidays in Edinburgh can sell out a month out. Same-day spots do open up when other travelers cancel, so it is worth checking if you are already in town.
What should I bring or wear?
+
Bring photo ID, your booking confirmation on your phone, a refillable water bottle and comfortable shoes. Dress for the weather in Edinburgh and add a light layer if any part of the 2-hour experience runs outdoors or after sunset.
Where does Crime and Punishment start and how do I get there?
+
The exact meeting point and directions are on your voucher once you book, and they sit in central Edinburgh within reach of public transport. Arrive 15 minutes early: late arrivals are treated as no-shows by most operators.
What are the best things to do in Edinburgh?
+
On Outty we rank every Edinburgh experience on the same 0 to 100 scale, and alongside this one the highest scorers right now include The Chocolatarium Chocolate Tour Experience in Edinburgh, The Mountebank Comedy Walk of Edinburgh, Edinburgh Old Town: Historical Guided Walking Tour. The city page groups everything into most popular, highest reviewed, last minute and family-friendly so you can build a day around what actually delivers.
When is the best time to visit Edinburgh?
+
Booking patterns follow the same curve: prices and queues climb in peak weeks, while shoulder season gives you better availability on the top-ranked experiences and more room to change plans.
How many days do you need in Edinburgh?
+
Three full days covers the headline sights without sprinting. A workable rhythm is one anchor experience each morning, such as this one, an unhurried afternoon in a single neighborhood, then a food or nightlife booking in the evening. Five days lets you add a day trip outside the city.
Do I book through Outty or through the operator?
+
Outty ranks and explains the experiences, then hands you to Viator to complete the booking with the operator directly. The price is the same as booking on Viator yourself, and Outty earns an affiliate commission on the referral, which is how the rankings stay free to read.
What is included in Crime and Punishment?
+
Included: 2hr Historical Walking Tour; and Guide. Not included: Gratuities. Always check the voucher for the final list before you travel.
Where is the meeting point for Crime and Punishment?
+
In front of St Giles Cathedral, by the Statue, Look for your costumed Guide carrying a large umbrella with our company name on it. Note, we do not always use an umbrella as it depends upon the weather. Hotel pickup is not included, so plan your own transport and arrive 15 minutes early.
What languages is Crime and Punishment offered in?
+
It runs in English. Pick your language when choosing a date and time, as not every departure runs in every language.
Will I get instant confirmation and a mobile ticket for Crime and Punishment?
+
Confirmation is sent by the operator after booking, usually within 48 hours; if it is not confirmed you are not charged. Mobile tickets are accepted, so you can show the voucher on your phone.
Is Crime and Punishment wheelchair or stroller accessible?
+
The operator notes: Infants and small children can ride in a pram or stroller; All areas and surfaces are wheelchair accessible; Transportation options are wheelchair accessible; and Wheelchair accessible. If accessibility is critical, contact the operator after booking to confirm arrangements for your date.
What happens to Crime and Punishment if the weather is bad?
+
This experience depends on good weather. If it is canceled because of poor weather, you are offered a different date or a full refund.
Ready to lock in your spot?
Pick a date, choose your group, and see the exact price for Crime and Punishment.
Pick your date




